Awards
2019
- Top Women in Convenience – Convenience Store News
- Top 25 Greatest Coffee Programs – CSP
2018
- Rutter’s has been selected as the 2018 Foodservice Innovator of the Year – CS News
- Ryan Krebs won Best Tasting Dish at the 2018 Convenience Foodservice Exchange – CS News
- Ranked #5 on List of Top 250 Privately Held Companies in Central PA – Central Penn Business Journal
- Rutter’s Wins Mystery Shops 2018 – CSP/Intouch Insight
- Top Women in Convenience – Convenience Store News
- #13 Most Effective Gasoline Brand – CSP
- #1 in Menu Variety – Technomic
- Rutter’s Director of Foodservice Wins Produce Excellence Award – United Fresh
- Jere Matthews Ranked on CSP’s Power 20: Change Makers – CSP
- Top 25 Greatest Coffee Programs – CSP
2017
- #1 in Menu Variety – CSP
- Ryan Krebs: 2017 Foodservice Leader of the Year – CSNews
- Greatest C-Store Design for a Store Within a Store – CSP
- Top Women in Convenience – Convenience Store News
- #1 Retailer Conquering Foodservice – Convenience Store Products
- #1 Spot in CSP’s Mystery Shop – CSP
- Kid-Friendly Convenience Store Chain – CSP
- Scott Hartman Inducted into Candy Hall of Fame – CSP
- Top Convenience Store Chain in 25 Greatest Coffee Programs – CSP
2016
- Top C-Store Chains With Cleanest Restrooms – CSP
- Ranked #5 on List of Top 100 Privately Held Companies in Central PA – Central Penn Business Journal
- Healthiest Convenience Store Chain – CSP
- Convenience Store Retailer of the Year – The Griffin Report of Food Marketing
- Top Women in Convenience – Convenience Store News
- National Convenience Store Survey – Ranked 1st in Brand Fit and Loyalty – Ranked 2nd in Best Food and Beverage – Technomic
- Cornerstone Award – SpiriTrust Lutheran
- Best of York – Nominated in Coffee, Milk, Convenience Store, Quick Service Restaurant, and Wings Categories – York Daily Record/Sunday News
2015
- Top Women in Convenience – Convenience Store News
- Best of York – Nominated in Quick Service Lunch, Quick Service Dinner, Milk, and Coffee Categories – York Daily Record/Sunday News
- Ranked #1 on List of Top 100 Privately Held Companies in York County – Central Penn Business Journal
- Ranked #2 on List of Top 100 Privately Held Companies in Central PA – Central Penn Business Journal
2014
- International Convenience Retailer of the Year -“ NACS/Insight
- Store Operations Superstar Award – Customer Engagement – Retail Touchpoints Magazine
- Best Milk – York Newspaper Company
- Best of York – Nominated in Coffee, Milk, Quick Service Breakfast, Quick Service Lunch, and Quick Service Dinner Categories – York Daily Record/Sunday News
- Mechanicsburg Recycling Award – Mechanicsburg Borough
2013
- Best Prepared Food Innovator – CSNews Magazine
- Pennsylvania Convenience Store Chain of the Year – Griffin Publishing
- Ranked on List of 50 Fastest Growing Companies in Central PA – Central Penn Business Journal
- Ranked #1 on List of Top 100 Privately Held Companies in York County – Central Penn Business Journal
- Ranked #2 on List of Top 100 Privately Held Companies in Central PA – Central Penn Business Journal
2012
- Food Service Retailer of the Year – CSNews Magazine
- Best Mobile Application Award – Retail TouchPoints Magazine – National Retail Federation
2011
- Outstanding Technology Implementation Award – CSNews Magazine
2010
- Convenience Store Chain of the Year – Convenience Store Decisions Magazine
2009
- Best New Food Service Concept of the Year – Convenience Store Decisions Magazine
- Eco Superhero Award – CSP Magazine & Captain Planet Foundation
- Spirit Award for Community Outreach – CSNews Magazine
- Corporate Citizen of the Year – Pennsylvania Citizens for Better Libraries
2008
- Convenience Store Innovator of the Year – Griffin Publishing
2005
- Business of the Year – Central Penn Business Journal
